BaconLover
Founding Member
Very valid points indeed.I think you are both right and both wrong as the only way to be sure is to run scientifically controlled tests were side by side markets exist for the same securities one of which allows shorts to participate and one which does not.
The obvious flaw in being adamant about the merits of either market position is to assume that if shorting is outlawed shorts will no longer participate in the market in some other form and become house painters or fashion designers.
The reality is if they cannot short then then will turn to trading or investing and so will still be an influence in the markets.
The only thing I know is that shorting stock is not illegal.
Manipulating the market either as a short, a trader or an investor is a criminal offence.
I say up the Government investigation and prosecution of manipulators of all types. Gaol them and ban them from participating in the markets for life. Confiscate their proceeds of crime. Then put them in the stocks and make tomatoes tax deductible and after ten days whip them to an inch of their lives then draw and quarter them. Rehabilitation and retraining can then be made available on a compulsory basis in the unlikely event they survive the process.
My opinion only DYOR
FF
AKIDA BALLISTA
While I don't mind people short trading, I must clarify, I don't like when they spread fear among investors to gain advantage.
As to your scientific evidence question, I know along with Australia, countries like France, Spain, Italy, Canada etc banned short selling during 2008'09 saga. Australia reinstated it as we know, not sure how other countries are going. If someone is involved in those countries' exchanges might be able to comment.
I assume there'll be still the factor of spreading fear in order for them to enter cheaply in a stock.
This statement might be controversial, but some may remember posters bashing BRN so much on HC a few years ago until they got their fill, and then turned to be pro Akida once they got their shares.
So whether short sales are gone or not, those with less integrity will continue to do their thing, when it's $$$$ on the line. Investors just will need to keep doing their DD, and as FF often says, have a plan and execute it without fail.